The
Report
Updates and Information for our valued clients
David F. Boothe • President
​
450 Kings Hwy N.E. • Dover, DE 19901
302-734-7526 • aBIGplan.com
July 2024
I’ve spent a lot of time on the water. We were once taking a boat down to Florida from the Chesapeake Bay with our first stop being the Oregon Inlet in North Carolina which is considered to be one of the most dangerous inlets in the world. I was well prepared with the latest and most up to date navigational charts, GPS, radar, sonar and had picked a beautifully calm day. As we approached the inlet following the GPS generated course, I didn’t like what I saw. The charts were taking me right through a spot of breakers and tan colored water. Now if I deferred to the charts, I would have likely stranded the boat on a sandbar where the breakers would have destroyed and probably sunk the boat. Instead, I throttled back, and studied the water and started taking a different course. While heading in, I spotted a local workboat, tucked in behind it and safely followed it in from sea.
The point of the story…. sometimes you have to throttle back and study the water and then look for a safer way through what may lie ahead.
If the water is the economy and the navigational charts are the market, I think the charts could be off and moving forward is going to be trickier than it has been as of late.
Outside of a brief pullback in April, the market has been extremely complacent. We had raised some cash and were able to take advantage of the April drawdown by doing some buying. But navigating the second half of 2024 may be like navigating the Oregon Inlet on a stormy day.
First, the presidential election. One thing the market hates is uncertainty and I think everyone would agree that we’re facing a lot of uncertainty in regards to the election. Quite honestly, after the most recent debate and related news stories, I would have expected that our country would be in the midst of a sincere conversation about who should be running the country between now and election day rather than the election itself. Where we see concern, our adversaries may see opportunity and November is still far away. Unfortunately, both sides seem more concerned about politics and power than the immediate need for competent leadership. We will hope things stay tame on the geopolitical front between now and November and expect some volatility caused by election headlines.
Next are the cracks in the economy. The unemployment rate is ticking higher while prior month job numbers are being significantly revised to the downside. Job openings are down significantly. Credit card defaults are growing, and consumer spending appears to be softening. Lumber prices, which have been a 6-to-9-month harbinger of recession throughout history have recently plummeted. Services ISM (Institute of Supply Management) numbers showed sudden and significant signs of weakness joining the already weak ISM manufacturing numbers. All of this is occurring while we find ourselves in the longest yield curve inversion in U.S. history. The importance of the yield curve inversion was discussed in last quarter’s newsletter and can be found on our website. The water is looking dangerous.
Then there’s the weak breadth of the market. The S&P 500 is up 15% for the year while the average stock in the S&P is only up 5%. The difference being driven by the top 7 stocks in the market. The Dow Jones is only up 4% on the year and the small cap index is flat. There are many pockets in the market that are simply NOT participating in this rally. The question is, are they making a statement and telling a different
story, or will they play catch up in the near future? I think it may be a little of both. They may be telling a different story of the pain of high rates and a slowing consumer but many of these lagging areas have a history of outperforming after the first rate cut. So, we may likely see a broadening of the market and a greater participation in the gains after the first rate cut only to have things settle back down if those economic cracks lead to more.
Speaking of rate cuts, we can’t dismiss the Federal Reserve and their interest rate policies. I’ve been comfortable with the Fed holding tight up until about a month ago. The Fed has a history of always waiting too late to take their foot off the brake. I understand they’ve been extremely fearful of a resurgence of inflation, but the economic cracks are very concerning. I think the Fed needs to start cutting now. It may already be too late, but I think if the Fed refuses to cut by September in response to the weakening economic data, a recession in 2025 becomes much more probable. Even still, a recession is better than hyper-inflation. If inflation stays stubborn and the Fed errs toward inflationary concerns, I wouldn’t fault them. We can easily get through a recession.
Finally, there’s the valuation of the market. The market is expensive, PERIOD. The only way for it to become less expensive is for earnings to expand substantially and soon or for the market to fall. Companies may be able to pull off increasing earnings by focusing on their margins as they did in the most recent quarter. The concern we have is that the top line growth has been weak in a lot of areas. Companies have had higher earnings with less revenue. That type of margin expansion to meet numbers can only last for so long. Eventually, all the financial engineering and expense cutting has been done and you simply need more sales and revenue to grow profits. Profits MUST grow to support the current valuation of the stock market. It’s expensive and earnings need to rapidly expand, or the market needs to take a step back.
I know we didn’t discuss the National Debt whose interest expense is about to overtake defense spending to become our third largest expense. If rates don’t fall soon, it’s on track to become our largest expense in the very near future. Although a problem, we don’t believe we’re at the cliff’s edge yet and will talk more about this in future newsletters.
The charts of presidential election years suggest a robust August, weak September, dismal October followed by a strong post election rebound regardless of outcome. We expect similar market movements to the past with some extra volatility given the uncertain nature of this particular election.
Near-term concerns aside, I believe the market can give us another 10% to 15% gain between now and the first quarter of 2025. We may have a 5% to 10% drop between now and then but we do think the market will reach higher levels.
Even with that expectation, we want to be somewhat cautious. Unlike most of our peers, we have not dismissed the possibility of a recession in 2025 or 2026. As such, we will continue to take a very disciplined and measured approach moving forward by utilizing higher levels of bonds in our models. Bonds are paying great rates of interest that we haven’t seen in 16 years and with the Fed’s next moves likely being cuts than hikes, bonds can do even better if rates are falling. When the stock market gets choppy and it surely will at some point, bonds will be the old workboat that we can follow through one of the most dangerous inlets in the world…
David F. Boothe
​President, Financial Advisor, Boat Captain
Boothe Investment Group Inc. (“B.I.G. Investment Services”) is a registered investment adviser offering advisory services in the State(s) of DE, FL, MD, NC, PA, TX, VA and in other jurisdictions where exempted. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Opinions expressed herein are solely those of B.I.G. Investment Services, unless otherwise specifically cited. Material presented is believed to be from reliable sources and no representations are made by our firm as to another parties’ informational accuracy or completeness. All investing involves risk, including the potential for loss of principal. There is no guarantee that any investment plan or strategy will be successful.