The
Report
Updates and Information for our valued clients
David F. Boothe • President
​
450 Kings Hwy N.E. • Dover, DE 19901
302-734-7526 • aBIGplan.com
October 2024
I’ve recently learned that the end of America is upon us, at least according to most people that I speak with. The country appears to be dramatically divided as we draw close to the 2024 presidential election and depending on who you talk to, it’s game over for America if either candidate wins the race. Yes, in either case, America ceases to exist. Trump supporters expect disaster upon a Harris win and Harris supporters expect disaster upon a Trump win. Both can’t be right.
The truth is, the market doesn’t care that much about the presidency. If you look at the chart below, you’ll find the market goes up AND down with either democrats or republicans at the helm.
​​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​​
​
​
​
​
What concerns the market the most are sweeps of both the White House and Congress. The market tends to perform best under a mixed, which often means gridlocked, government. The market figures that if legislators can’t pass anything, they can’t break anything because let’s face it, incompetence abounds on both sides.
​
That’s not to say there aren’t things to be cognizant of as we approach election day. For example, a democrat sweep of the White House and Congress in 2024 will surely mean the end of the 2017 tax cuts which are set to expire at the end of 2025. A study of IRS tax return data showed that one year later, those tax cuts resulted in a 15 to 26 percent reduction of taxes paid for those making less than $100,000 a year, and a reduction of 6 to 9% for those making over $500,000 with the percentage of benefit shrinking with higher incomes.
Many times, we get caught up in political hyperbole like “tax cuts for the rich” but as we just saw with the numbers above, these can be dishonest spins on the truth. The question to ask is “who is defined as rich”? Would we consider the top 25% of all wage earners to be rich? Well, that group is made up of people making over $94,440 and they pay 89% of all income tax paid in America. So any tax cut is going to benefit the top 25% of wage earners, are they the rich? How about the top 5% of wager earners? Those making over $252,840 a year pay 65% of all income tax. The top 1% of earners pay almost 46% of all income tax. The bottom 50% of all wage earners only pay 2.3% of the tax.
So with 75% of all wage earners paying only 11% of all income tax, ANY tax cut can be construed to be a tax cut for the rich when “the rich” go undefined.
Conversely, tariffs aren’t necessarily the end all be all of international political tools. While we want to be smart and strive to ensure a level playing field for American business, we have to be careful to not drive up prices or cause retaliatory policies that will hurt American citizens and business interests. ​
There were tariff announcements during the Trump administration that appeared reactionary and resulted in unintended consequences on multiple occasions with emergency exceptions having to be made to protect large American employers such as Apple.
Policies on both sides can elicit negative market reactions. If neither party has the power to completely have their way, the market sighs a breath of relief as any potential damage should be limited.
​
If there is any economic issue facing the country in which politics plays a major role, it’s the national debt. Throughout my 25 years managing money, I’ve had a lot of people raise concerns about the national debt. They would be panicking as we hit “all time highs” on the levels of debt our country was racking up. I explained at the time that the proper way to evaluate our debt position was in relation to the economy. After all, most of our retired clients paid more for their most recent automobile than they did their first home but their incomes are much higher as well. Inflation causes us to have to evaluate the debt issue in relative terms by using gross domestic product or GDP which measures the size of our economy.
Our highest debt to GDP occurred during World War II at 120%. So as we hit all time dollar highs of 6 trillion, 10 trillion and 12 trillion, our debt to GDP was still well under 100%. That changed coming into 2024 as we approach 35 trillion in debt resulting in our debt to GDP crossing 120% for the first time since World War II.
It can be said that we’ve been here before and worked our way out but there’s a HUGE difference between this time and last. As I mentioned in a previous newsletter, the last time we were here, there was no Medicare, no CIA, no Departments of Homeland Security or Education, no NASA. Even Social Security only covered a widow whose life expectancy was lower than the age they were allowed to first start collecting. Here we are 80 years later hitting 120% debt to GDP but unlike last time, we have 214 trillion dollars of unfunded liabilities and we’re giving away money we don’t have to people all around the world.
It’s much more likely that our lack of fiscal responsibility will cause the death of America, not the next president. So don’t sweat the presidential election as it relates to the stock market but be concerned about fiscal responsibility down the ballot.
The market tends to have ugly Octobers in presidential election years and then tends to rally very strong from the election into year end. The market has accomplished some things in recent weeks that indicate it is poised for a strong finish so unless things change, we would expect a similar path for the remainder of 2024.
2025 is shaping up to be a different story as we see some economic developments and market action that we find concerning. We don’t expect anything dramatic but we’re not as convinced as many market pontificators that we’re going to have the coveted, elusive and extremely rare, “soft landing”.
There’s a lot to talk about regarding next year but we’ll take a deep dive on those expectations with the next newsletter as we provide our 2025 outlook. Well, barring the end of America between now and December.
Have a wonderful Thanksgiving and Christmas be sure to tune in to our weekly podcast or reach out if you have any questions or concerns in the meantime.
David F. Boothe
​President, Financial Advisor, Boat Captain
Boothe Investment Group Inc. (“B.I.G. Investment Services”) is a registered investment adviser offering advisory services in the State(s) of DE, FL, MD, NC, PA, TX, VA and in other jurisdictions where exempted. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Opinions expressed herein are solely those of B.I.G. Investment Services, unless otherwise specifically cited. Material presented is believed to be from reliable sources and no representations are made by our firm as to another parties’ informational accuracy or completeness. All investing involves risk, including the potential for loss of principal. There is no guarantee that any investment plan or strategy will be successful.